[I didn't include my answer, because it was a few pages
long... as you may remember]

So let's consider your first comment of:

"First of all, the comment insinuates that the woman is
a lesbian, or does not deserve a decent guy in her life.
Lesbians in this country are in a minority and their rights
are protected by law. All women have the right to choose
their partner, whether male or female. Women also have the
right to choose the most compatible male available. This
person, in my friends opinion, does not deserve the time of
the day from that particular woman for being so insulting
to her face."

Lesbians are a minority? The comment insinuates that she's
a lesbian? Women have the RIGHT to choose the "most
compatible male available"?

Can I ask you PLEASE PASS ME THE CRACK PIPE, because it's
obviously some good stuff. I mean, you MUST be high.

My comments are only taking away from the beautiful
comedy that you've already created in this heartfelt
paragraph, so I'll continue with your next...

"Second, the comment slaps the woman in the face.
The woman at the gym may have problems finding and keeping
a boyfriend. She may be shy. That comment is a good way to
injure a woman's delicate psyche."

The only problem that the woman at the gym was having is
the ability to TELL THE TRUTH! Hell, she opened her
mouth and lied to a complete stranger without even being
spoken to.

The reason she might have a problem "finding and keeping a
boy friend" is that she's a liar! I don't know a lot of
people that feel compelled to lie to people they've never
met or spoken to, but this is a little red flag, in my
humble opinion. And it's surely NOT a sign of SHYNESS.

LOL! You're killing me.